The tension surrounding Giancarlo Stanton‘s return to the New York Yankees lineup continues to build as the team prepares for a pivotal series at Fenway Park. After a standout performance during his rehab assignment with the Double-A Somerset Patriots, expectations are rising—but clarity remains elusive. Fans and analysts alike are closely watching Stanton’s status as the Yankees eye reinforcements for the high-stakes showdown against the Boston Red Sox.

Tuesday’s game in Somerset delivered promising signs. Stanton went 2-for-3, including a 111.4 mph drive to the left-center gap, and tallied three RBIs. Manager Aaron Boone confirmed that the veteran slugger would play in consecutive games before the team regroups Thursday, making a Friday return at Fenway a realistic possibility. Still, no official decision has been made.

When asked by the TheAtletic’s Brendan Kuty about his availability, Stanton gave a reserved but revealing three-word response: “I don’t know.” The remark has stirred speculation across the Yankees organization and fanbase, underscoring the uncertainty ahead of a critical stretch in the AL East race.

Stanton’s track record at Fenway encourages optimism

Stanton’s career numbers at Fenway Park are more than encouraging. Across 37 games, he has slashed .312/.384/.532 with seven home runs and 24 RBIs, alongside 16 extra-base hits. That kind of production could be decisive in a rivalry series with playoff implications. However, the Yankees remain cautious, aiming to ensure the slugger’s durability down the stretch.

Giancarlo Stanton at the plate during a past appearance, as questions linger about his return to the Yankees lineup. (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)

The team is expected to make a decision Thursday after evaluating Stanton’s consecutive starts with Somerset. Boone and the training staff are closely monitoring his readiness to handle daily action. Given Stanton’s injury history, the organization is balancing immediate needs with long-term health.

Looking ahead

If Stanton gets the green light, Friday’s opener at Fenway will mark a symbolic and strategic milestone. For now, the Yankees will complete their internal assessments, with all eyes on how Stanton emerges from his rehab finale. Regardless of the final call, his looming return adds a compelling layer to one of baseball’s most storied rivalries.

SURVEY Should the Yankees activate Giancarlo Stanton for the Fenway series?

Should the Yankees activate Giancarlo Stanton for the Fenway series?

Yes — if he's physically ready, it's the right time
No — better to wait and avoid re-injury
Only if the lineup lacks power without him
Trust the training staff to make the call

already voted 8 fans