NHL

Maple Leafs HC Craig Berube fires back after Sam Bennett’s controversial hit leaves Anthony Stolarz sidelined

Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube didn’t hold back after Florida Panthers' Sam Bennett’s unpenalized hit left Anthony Stolarz injured and out of Game 1.

Head Coach Craig Berube of the Toronto Maple Leafs fields questions after a victory against the Florida Panthers in Game One of the Second Round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scotiabank Arena on May 5, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
© Photo by Claus Andersen/Getty ImagesHead Coach Craig Berube of the Toronto Maple Leafs fields questions after a victory against the Florida Panthers in Game One of the Second Round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scotiabank Arena on May 5, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

The Toronto Maple Leafs may have secured a critical 5-4 win over the Florida Panthers to open their second-round series, but the aftermath focused less on the scoreboard and more on a controversial moment involving goaltender Anthony Stolarz. The veteran netminder was forced out of the game following a blow to the head that has now become the center of scrutiny.

Advertisement

The incident unfolded midway through the second period when Sam Bennett made contact with Stolarz’s head at the 7:20 mark. Despite the visible hit, officials allowed play to continue without issuing a penalty.

Stolarz remained in net briefly but vomited on the bench during a stoppage, prompting immediate medical attention. He exited the game and was later transported to a local hospital from Scotiabank Arena for evaluation.

Advertisement

Berube calls It “Clear as Day”

Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube did not mince words postgame, calling out the lack of a penalty and expressing frustration over the league’s inaction on what he described as a dangerous play. “Elbow to the head, clearly. Clear as day,” Berube stated. “I’m not sure why there’s not a call on it. I get it, they miss calls. But it’s clearly a penalty.

Tweet placeholder
Advertisement

The coach confirmed that Stolarz was undergoing medical evaluation but withheld further comment. “That is all I have for you on Stolarz. I wouldn’t keep commenting on it,” he added.

Former NHL player sends big warning to Tkachuk, Bennett, Marchand, the rest of the Panthers before Round 2 series

see also

Maurice dismisses concerns

While Berube deferred to the NHL regarding possible supplemental discipline, his counterpart offered a far different tone. Panthers head coach Paul Maurice initially appeared indifferent when asked about the collision. Not nearly as good as the referee’s vantage point. He was standing right there. He saw it, he said before abruptly shutting down the line of questioning. “You’re all going to light your hair on fire, and I’m going to let you. I’ve answered one on it,” Maurice snapped.

Advertisement

Survey

What should the NHL do about Sam Bennett's hit on Anthony Stolarz?

already voted 0 people

Game 2 looms with goaltending in question

Before his departure, Stolarz had allowed one goal on nine shots. Backup Joseph Woll took over and made 17 saves on 20 attempts, helping Maple Leafs withstand a final push from Florida. As the series heads into Game 2 on Wednesday in Toronto, all eyes will be on the Leafs’ crease — and whether the league opts to revisit Bennett’s hit that has already left its mark on the series.

Advertisement
ALSO READ
Maurice provides injury updates on Marchand’s key Panthers teammates
NHL

Maurice provides injury updates on Marchand’s key Panthers teammates

Bennett issues tough-love message to key Panthers teammate
NHL

Bennett issues tough-love message to key Panthers teammate

Not Tkachuk, Marchand, or Bennett—Stanley Cup champ names Panthers' game-changer
NHL

Not Tkachuk, Marchand, or Bennett—Stanley Cup champ names Panthers' game-changer

After re-signing Marchand, Bennett, and Ekblad, Panthers reportedly found sweet-spot for key extension
NHL

After re-signing Marchand, Bennett, and Ekblad, Panthers reportedly found sweet-spot for key extension

Better Collective Logo