Isiah Thomas, the Hall of Fame point guard and iconic leader of the Detroit Pistons‘ “Bad Boys” era, remains one of the most revered competitors in NBA history. A two-time champion and 12-time All-Star, Thomas helped redefine what it meant to be a floor general, leading with grit, intelligence, and unwavering toughness. Recently, the legendary guard opened up about the toughest defenders he faced during his decorated career.
In a 2023 interview, Thomas named his top three defenders of all time, including two former Chicago Bulls stars and one of the greatest two-way centers in league history. While he claimed he wasn’t ranking them, Thomas has previously gone on record stating that Scottie Pippen tops his list as the best defender in NBA history, with Dennis Rodman coming in second.
“As a defender, he doesn’t get enough credit,” Thomas said on the ALL THE SMOKE podcast. “When we talk about the greatest and best defenders that have ever played in the NBA, Chicago had two of them — Rodman and Scottie Pippen.”
“Scottie was different,” Thomas continued. “At his best, I may have to say that he and Rodman were the one-two best defenders to ever play the game. I want to give him his respect and his props. And then, as a facilitator, Scottie — he was the real deal.”
Thomas vs Pippen: A storied rivalry
The rivalry between Isiah Thomas and Scottie Pippen took shape in the late 1980s, when the Detroit Pistons and Chicago Bulls became perennial Eastern Conference contenders. As the fiery leader of the Pistons, Thomas personified the physical, confrontational style of basketball that defined the era and often frustrated the rising Bulls, led by Michael Jordan and supported by a maturing Pippen.
Those postseason battles were nothing short of legendary. Detroit’s “Jordan Rules” didn’t just target Jordan—they also tested Pippen’s resilience. The Bulls forward, still emerging as a star, took repeated hits from Detroit’s bruising defense, both physically and psychologically. Thomas, never shy in front of a mic, frequently questioned Pippen’s toughness and leadership compared to Jordan, fueling a personal and professional feud that has lingered long after their careers ended.
Rodman’s complex connection with Thomas
Dennis Rodman’s relationship with Thomas was more layered. Originally teammates on the Pistons, the two helped shape Detroit’s identity as the NBA’s most feared defensive unit. Rodman’s energy, versatility, and defensive prowess complemented Thomas’s leadership during their back-to-back title runs in 1989 and 1990.
However, Rodman’s eventual move to the Bulls in the mid-1990s complicated their legacy. By joining Chicago — the very franchise Detroit had built its identity around defeating — Rodman became part of the dynasty the Pistons once stood against. The dynamic shifted, and while mutual respect remained, the symbolism of Rodman wearing a Bulls jersey stung for many Pistons loyalists, including Thomas.
More than a rivalry — a cultural divide
Despite moments of mutual respect among all three players, personal pride and competitive fire have long fueled the tension between Thomas, Pippen, and Rodman. For Thomas, the Pistons’ legacy — one forged in sweat, defense, and defiance — is too often overlooked in favor of the flashier narratives surrounding the Bulls dynasty. He continues to be a vocal advocate for what Detroit represented during its golden years.
Their rivalry was more than physical — it was deeply cultural and symbolic. It wasn’t just about winning games; it was about defining eras, identities, and ultimately, greatness. And for Isiah Thomas, those matchups — and those defenders — are etched into NBA history with the intensity they brought to every possession.