New York Yankees fans are often the first to criticize players for poor performance, especially when it involves not covering their positions well. Anthony Volpe recently became a “victim” of that punishment, as he was booed by the crowd at Yankee Stadium.

The stadium was once again the scene of a bad play by Volpe, the kind that makes people question whether he should continue playing at that position. He fielded an easy ball, but instead of throwing it to first base, he chose to throw it to second, a decision the crowd did not like.

Fortunately, Volpe wasn’t alone, as Aaron Boone defended him with a lengthy message trying to justify the shortstop’s decision, a play that would lead to him being booed by fans and heavily criticized on social media.

Yankees Fans Boo Volpe

It is not the first time Yankees fans have booed one of their own players, but with Volpe, the criticism is becoming normal due to the number of errors and poor plays he has had this year, especially at a sensitive position like shortstop.

“If you’re going to use Giancarlo Stanton off the bench there in the eighth, and not save him for Aroldis Chapman in the ninth, then why not pinch hit him for Anthony Volpe instead of Ryan McMahon?” Max Goodman wrote on X.

Fans Online Turn Against Volpe

People on social media were calling for the Yankees to use Jose Caballero at shortstop—saying that’s why he was brought to the team—and to bench Volpe immediately to “heal the situation” at the position.

“Anthony Volpe is putting together one of the worst stretches of baseball I’ve ever seen since my college career,” one fan wrote on X. Another said, “The Yankees have to bench Anthony Volpe for Jose Caballero for the rest of this series. If Ben Rice can catch this shouldn’t be a problem.”