NY Yankees pleased with Caballero, can’t guarantee Volpe’s starting shortstop role upon return

The New York Yankees continue to roll in the AL East. Their performance has been outstanding, and one of the keys has been finding answers in Jose Caballero following Anthony Volpe’s injury. Looking ahead, Aaron Boone will evaluate every detail regarding the team’s shortstop position.

“We’ll see. We’ll continue to talk about that. Again, Jose’s played himself into and earned himself more playing time. I love the idea of Jose being in that kind of super-utility role because he’s so good at it,” the manager said when asked if the Yankees’ plans about Volpe being the starting shortstop have changed.

Boone, true to his style, also stated that he will always prioritize the team over individual players. “At the end of the day, we’re going to try and do what’s best for our team and then individual players that we care about too and know that are going to be important contributors to our team. We weigh all that.”

Caballero backs up Boone’s words with strong play

Through 33 games of the 2026 season, the Yankees boast a 22-11 record, with Jose Caballero appearing in 31 of those contests as the primary shortstop. He has maintained a .266 average with 29 hits, 4 home runs, and 12 RBIs, while his 12 stolen bases have been crucial in keeping the team at the top of the standings. While Caballero has been a spark plug in nearly every game, his elite defensive play has been just as vital to the Yankees‘ strong start.

Jose Caballero #72 of the New York Yankees.

Volpe’s injury and potential return

See also

NY Yankees receive encouraging Giancarlo Stanton update amid Cole, Rodon nearing return

Anthony Volpe is nearing a return to the Yankees after undergoing surgery on October 14 to repair a partially torn labrum in his left shoulder. The injury, which occurred during a dive in May 2025, was more severe than initial imaging suggested and significantly hampered his performance last season.

After a successful rehab assignment with Double-A Somerset where he batted .303, he is physically ready to be activated. However, the Yankees have delayed his return until at least Monday, May 4.