MLB

Yankees' big win? Ex-MLB All-Star calls missing Juan Soto ‘a blessing in disguise’

An unexpected take from an Ex-MLB All-Star claims the Yankees' roster moves after missing out on Juan Soto could make them even stronger this offseason.

Juan Soto of the New York Mets poses with his new uniform after his introductory press conference at Citi Field on December 12, 2024 in New York City.
© Photo by Al Bello/Getty ImagesJuan Soto of the New York Mets poses with his new uniform after his introductory press conference at Citi Field on December 12, 2024 in New York City.

Juan Soto‘s decision to sign with the New York Mets, turning down a historic offer from the New York Yankees, sent shockwaves through Major League Baseball. The move not only shifted the league’s balance of power but also sparked intense debate among fans and analysts alike.

In the wake of Juan Soto‘s departure, the Yankees wasted no time fortifying their roster. The acquisition of ace pitcher Max Fried and elite reliever Devin Williams has significantly bolstered the team’s pitching depth. Additionally, the signing of Cody Bellinger brings much-needed versatility and offensive firepower to their lineup.

However, a surprising perspective from former MLB All-Star catcher A.J. Pierzynski suggests that losing Soto might actually work in the Yankees’ favor: “They missed out on Juan Soto… but I think they’re a better team now with Fried, Devin Williams, and Cody Bellinger than they were with just Juan Soto,” Pierzynski said on Foul Territory TV. “Them missing out… it might be a blessing in disguise for the Yankees over the long haul.”

Advertisement

A New Vision for the Yankees

Soto’s decision forced the Yankees to pivot, and the result has been a series of calculated moves that could create a more balanced and competitive roster. Instead of focusing on one superstar, the Yankees have added multiple impact players, strengthening their overall depth and team cohesion.

Tweet placeholder
Advertisement

Pierzynski highlighted the Yankees’ strategic shift: Yes, I know the Mets’ season tickets are through the roof… they should be. But the Yankees’ season tickets are going to be through the roof too, when you look at their starting rotation. They now have a lock-down closer and a center fielder/first baseman in a guy that people know. If the Yankees do even more, they’re winning this offseason.”

MLB Rumors: Mets targeting blockbuster trade for $500 million star after landing Juan Soto

see also

Bright Future Ahead

Despite missing out on Soto, the Yankees have showcased adaptability and a forward-thinking approach. While losing the generational talent may have seemed like a setback, the team’s recent acquisitions suggest a renewed commitment to balance and sustainability. By focusing on building a deeper and more versatile roster, the Yankees are positioning themselves as contenders not just for this MLB season but for years to come.

Advertisement
ALSO READ
NY Yankees keep Astros trade in play while Bellinger future remains unclear
MLB

NY Yankees keep Astros trade in play while Bellinger future remains unclear

MLB News: Derek Shelton’s Twins add former NY Yankees player ahead of the 2026 season
MLB

MLB News: Derek Shelton’s Twins add former NY Yankees player ahead of the 2026 season

NY Yankees face serious Bellinger threat from emerging NL West contender
MLB

NY Yankees face serious Bellinger threat from emerging NL West contender

MLB Rumors: Cody Bellinger’s return to NY Yankees in question amid contract impasse, backup plans
MLB

MLB Rumors: Cody Bellinger’s return to NY Yankees in question amid contract impasse, backup plans

Better Collective Logo