nfl

NFL News: Aaron Rodgers should be Vikings QB1 instead of JJ McCarthy, says former Super Bowl champion

After Sam Darnold's departure, a former Super Bowl champion suggested that the Minnesota Vikings should pursue Aaron Rodgers. He also made bold remarks about JJ McCarthy, questioning the young quarterback's readiness.

Aaron Rodgers #8 of the New York Jets looks on before the game against the Los Angeles Chargers at MetLife Stadium on November 06, 2023 in East Rutherford, New Jersey.
Ā© Elsa/Getty ImagesAaron Rodgers #8 of the New York Jets looks on before the game against the Los Angeles Chargers at MetLife Stadium on November 06, 2023 in East Rutherford, New Jersey.

The Minnesota Vikings have finally ended one of the longest-running stories in their offseason: Sam Darnold’s departure from the franchise. In the aftermath, the team is now expected to place its trust in young quarterback JJ McCarthy as their starter. Following the move, a former Super Bowl champion weighed in, suggesting the Vikings should instead pursue veteran QB Aaron Rodgers. He even went as far as making a bold statement about McCarthy’s current performance.

Advertisement

Chase Daniel did not hold back when discussing the Minnesota Vikings’ quarterback situation. During an interview with The Athletic: ā€œIf you are the Vikings, pick the best quarterback out there and this is Aaron Rodgers. I understand what people are saying ā€˜Hey JJ McCarthy is future’, but he is an unproven rookie quarterback that played in Michigan and has very little snaps.ā€

Chase Daniel even praised Kevin O’Connell’s work as head coach: ā€œIf Kevin O’Connell can get Sam Darnold to 14 wins, what do you think he can do with Aaron Rodgers?…like much more talented quarterback. And who gets the best chance to win the Super Bowl Aaron Rodgers or JJ McCarthy? It’s easy, It’s Aaron Rodgers,ā€ explained Daniel. JJ McCarthy’s inexperience coupled with his questionable injury status make the Vikings’ gamble on him a risky one.

Advertisement

In addition, having in the possibility the addition of Aaron Rodgers, it sounds like a bad joke not to sign him. Especially because it would allow the franchise to win in the short term and also bet the future towards JJ McCarthy. Also, Chase Daniel made an impressive statement about the current level of JJ McCarthy: ā€œI’ve talked to people on the roster, ā€˜Hey, was this a competition? Would J.J. McCarthy actually have beaten out Sam Darnold?’ Absolutely not. The answer is a resounding no.ā€

Aaron Rodgers is a free agent for the first time in his career

Aaron Rodgers is a free agent for the first time in his career

Advertisement

Can the Vikings improve without adding a new quarterback for next season?

The Minnesota Vikings face a major challenge heading into next NFL season. They have yet to add a proven quarterback. Their current options, J.J. McCarthy and Brett Rypien, lack the experience needed for a deep playoff run. Last season, the Vikings relied on Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones. Their leadership proved crucial when McCarthy went down with an injury. Now, with both veterans gone, the Vikings must address their quarterback depth.

NFL News: Vikings snatch weapon from Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars amid Aaron Rodgers rumors

see also

If the Vikings rely only on JJ McCarthy and Brett Rypien, they could struggle even more than last season. McCarthy has a promising future, but he has not played enough to prove his talent. This makes trusting him a risky move. An injury to either quarterback would leave the team vulnerable.

Advertisement

To stay competitive, the Vikings must sign a seasoned quarterback. They need someone who can provide stability and leadership. Without that, improving next season will be difficult. Their playoff hopes could quickly disappear.

ALSO READ
Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games
NFL

Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?
NFL

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks
NFL

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?
NFL

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?

Better Collective Logo