The Toronto Maple Leafs are undergoing a notable identity shift following the offseason moves that included losing Mitch Marner and adding new players to their roster. However, many believe the real test of this transformation will come down to the performance of their star center, Auston Matthews.
While general manager Brad Treliving has spoken about changing the team’s “DNA,” there remains skepticism around whether these roster changes alone will solve Toronto’s playoff struggles. Matthews’ ability to lead in the postseason is now viewed as the pivotal factor in defining the team’s success.
TSN’s FirstUp hosts Aaron Korolnek and Dave Feschuk highlighted that the Maple Leafs’ playoff success hinges on Auston Matthews stepping up in critical moments. They stressed that the team’s true “DNA change” depends on Matthews evolving from a postseason underperformer to a player who consistently exceeds expectations: “The DNA change comes if Matthews goes from someone who underperforms in the playoffs to someone who overachieves.”
Why does Auston Matthews’ playoff performance matter most?
The Maple Leafs’ postseason hopes rest on Matthews breaking through. Last season, he recorded a career-high 11 points in 13 playoff games but once again faltered in critical moments, such as Game 7. Without a dominant showing from their captain, the team’s chances for deep playoff runs remain uncertain.
Auston Matthews #34 of the Toronto Maple Leafs skates against the Florida Panthers during the second period in Game Seven of the Second Round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scotiabank Arena on May 18, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Claus Andersen/Getty Images)
How Matthews’ bounce-back could extend Toronto’s championship window
Toronto’s championship window depends heavily on Matthews regaining his top form in the playoffs. If he can lead the offense and inspire his teammates, the new identity Treliving envisions may finally take hold and push the Maple Leafs closer to postseason glory.
see also
NHL News: Lightning star, two-time Stanley Cup Champ delivers ‘dream come true’ message on Sweden’s 2026 Olympic team
Survey Do you think the Maple Leafs can thrive in the playoffs with just one star leading the way after Mitch Marner’s exit?
Do you think the Maple Leafs can thrive in the playoffs with just one star leading the way after Mitch Marner’s exit?
ALREADY VOTED 0 PEOPLE
