The New York Yankees face a looming decision as Jazz Chisholm Jr. prepares to return from an oblique injury. With DJ LeMahieu healthy and active, the club must soon finalize how to configure its infield—and Chisholm isn’t hiding where he believes he fits best.
Before being sidelined, Chisholm had established himself as the Yankees’ everyday second baseman. Despite a .181 average across 125 plate appearances, he delivered seven home runs, 17 RBIs, and a .714 OPS. Even after nearly a month off the field, his 1.1 bWAR still ranks sixth among all Yankees hitters, underlining his all-around value.
As the club assesses its options, Chisholm has already shared his stance. Asked by The Athletic about potentially moving back to third base, the All-Star replied plainly: “It’s whatever. I already did it.” Though he handled third admirably after arriving from Miami last summer, Chisholm made it clear during the offseason—and through spring training usage—that second base is where he belongs.
A clear preference emerges as return nears
Chisholm wasn’t used at third base at all during camp, a sign the Yankees were leaning toward honoring his position preference. His statement to The Athletic subtly reinforces that mindset as the infield logjam resurfaces.
DJ LeMahieu #26 of the New York Yankees in action against the New York Mets during their game at Yankee Stadium on May 17, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)
Meanwhile, DJ LeMahieu has resumed playing at second base following his return from calf and hip issues. The veteran infielder has a long track record of versatility in New York, but his roots remain at second. Speaking recently about his current comfort level, LeMahieu said: “I feel really comfortable right now. I’m sure we’ll deal with it when we get there.”
see also
Aaron Boone delivers encouraging injury update on a teammate of Aaron Judge for Yankees fans
SurveyWho should be the Yankees’ everyday second baseman?
Who should be the Yankees’ everyday second baseman?
already voted 0 people
