Yankees' Devin Williams makes honest admission about season struggles amid bullpen controversy

The acquisition of Devin Williams by the New York Yankees was expected to bring stability and experience to the critical closer role in MLB. However, the beginning of his tenure in the Bronx has been marked by inconsistency—sparking inevitable comparisons, however unfair, to the legendary Mariano Rivera.

Williams’ early struggles have led to questions regarding Aaron Boone’s late-game strategy. The shadow cast by Rivera—who for two decades gave Yankees fans a near-unshakable sense of security in the final innings—is long and difficult to escape.

These concerns escalated following a recent outing in which Williams nearly squandered a substantial lead, reigniting the debate over whether he should remain the exclusive option in the ninth inning, particularly for a team with championship aspirations.

Devin Williams’ admission

“I haven’t felt like 100 percent myself up to this point,” Williams said, according to the New York Post. “But I would say I’m getting closer, for sure.” His comments suggest underlying factors that may be impacting his performance. Yet in the unforgiving rhythm of an MLB season, there is little room for extended struggles.

Devin Williams #38 of the New York Yankees celebrates after defeating the Milwaukee Brewers on Opening Day at Yankee Stadium on March 27, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images)

Boone facing the dilemma: Patience or action?

Aaron Boone has publicly backed Williams, aiming to instill confidence in the closer amid a rocky start. However, the competitive nature of MLB demands results, and patience can wear thin. The Yankees’ bullpen lacks a deep pool of proven closers, which limits immediate alternatives. While Luke Weaver has proven himself to be a valuable and versatile arm, he does not carry the recent résumé of a lockdown ninth-inning option.

see also

NY Yankees make big announcement on key piece of starting rotation to support Aaron Judge

What’s next for Williams and the Yankees?

The coming weeks will be pivotal for both Devin Williams and the Yankees’ bullpen. If his performance improves, the coaching staff’s initial faith may be rewarded. But should the struggles continue, Boonemay have no choice but to re-evaluate his closer strategy. The goal remains the same: secure victories and build a championship-caliber team—even if that requires difficult decisions about the most important outs of the game.