NFL

NFL News: Report confirms Vikings might be regretting their final decision to choose J.J. McCarthy over Aaron Rodgers

Whispers from inside the Vikings' camp suggest there's growing doubt over the decision to pick J.J. McCarthy as the starting quarterback instead of Aaron Rodgers.

J.J. McCarthy quarterback of the Minnesota Vikings
Ā© Michael Hickey/Getty ImagesJ.J. McCarthy quarterback of the Minnesota Vikings

The Minnesota Vikings were involved in many rumors about Aaron Rodgers as a possible alternative in case J.J. McCarthy didn’t convince them as the starting quarterback.

Advertisement

In the end, before the start of training camp, Kevin O’Connell gave full confidence to the Michigan university prospect, closing the door on Rodgers despite the great friendship he has with the veteran.

Aaron signed with the Pittsburgh Steelers aiming to win another Super Bowl in his career, and the Vikings are starting a new chapter after Sam Darnold left for the Seattle Seahawks. However, not everything seems to be going well for O’Connell and McCarthy.

Advertisement

Who will be Vikings starting quarterback?

J.J. McCarthy will be the starting quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings, but according to a surprising report from Colin Cowherd, there is concern within Kevin O’Connell’s coaching staff after what they have seen in training camp.

ā€œThere is this almost protective bubble or sort of an elevation of what he’s doing and it’s not what I’m hearing. That there are real concerns from last year on. What I’m hearing on J.J. McCarthy would not instill confidence.ā€

Advertisement
NFL imposes hefty suspension on J.J. McCarthy’s star teammate in Vikings’ latest controversy

see also

Dianna Russini supported this hypothesis in which the Vikings would be leaking positive information about McCarthy when, in reality, things may not have gone so well in the first practices leading up to the preseason.

ā€œIt sounds like it’s up and down. There’s some good, there’s some bad. There is a lot of lifting up of J.J. McCarthy. Do I think J.J. McCarthy is wowing everyone at training camp? No, I don’t. I think he’s fine. I’m not bought in all the way.ā€

Advertisement
ALSO READ
Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games
NFL

Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?
NFL

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks
NFL

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?
NFL

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?

Better Collective Logo