Sidney Crosby, Penguins reportedly at risk of losing key defenseman amid Hurricanes’ interest

The Pittsburgh Penguins could soon be facing a significant shakeup on their blue line—and Sidney Crosby might lose one of his most experienced teammates. As the offseason intensifies, one report links Erik Karlsson to a potential trade destination that could dramatically shift the Eastern Conference balance of power.

Following another bitter exit from the playoffs, the Carolina Hurricanes are evaluating all options to reinforce their defense. With Brent Burns now gone via free agency, Carolina’s front office appears focused on finding a high-end replacement on the right side—and Karlsson is reportedly at the top of the list.

NHL analyst Jeremy Tingly reported that Carolina seriously considered pursuing the Swedish defenseman. The team’s salary cap situation remains a hurdle, but the willingness to spend—and the Penguins’ potential to retain part of Karlsson’s contract—makes this scenario realistic.

Penguins could retain salary to facilitate deal

Karlsson, 34, carries a $10 million cap hit for two more seasons. That figure would typically dissuade suitors, but the Hurricanes’ position is unique. “The team lost Brent Burns to free agency this summer and now have a big hole to fill on the right side of their blueline,” Tingly wrote.

Erik Karlsson #65 and Sidney Crosby #87 of the Pittsburgh Penguins talk as they wait for a faceoff in the second period of a game against the Vegas Golden Knights at T-Mobile Arena on March 07, 2025 in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

He added: “It’s going to come down to money as Karlsson’s on the books for two more seasons at $10 million AAV, and if the Penguins will retain at least 20% of his remaining salary, the Hurricanes would apparently jump on the opportunity.”

see also

Connor McDavid’s Oilers believe rising star Matt Savoie is ready to take a major step forward this NHL season

Carolina’s defense was a major strength in recent years, but with Burns departing, the depth has taken a hit. Karlsson may not be in his prime, but he remains one of the league’s most productive puck-moving defensemen. Adding him would not only fill the immediate void left by Burns—it could also elevate Carolina’s transition game and offensive generation from the back end.

Hurricanes still in win-now mode

Despite repeated postseason setbacks, the Hurricanes remain firmly in win-now territory. General manager Eric Tulsky has already addressed a major offseason priority by retaining forward Nikolaj Ehlers, but the next move could define the team’s championship aspirations.

Karlsson’s combination of veteran leadership and high-end skill makes him an attractive target. The 2023 Norris Trophy winner could be exactly what head coach Rod Brind’Amour needs to push his team past the Florida Panthers and back into the Stanley Cup Final conversation.

Crosby’s core may shift again

For the Penguins, any trade involving Karlsson would represent another chapter in a series of transitions around Sidney Crosby. While management remains committed to keeping the team competitive around its captain, a trade involving Karlsson might also signal a longer-term retooling.

As training camps approach, Karlsson’s future remains one of the more intriguing storylines to watch. If Carolina is serious about taking that next step, the veteran Swede could soon be swapping black and gold for red and white.