Trending topics:
Olympics

Simone Biles vs Nadia Comaneci: Who is the greatest Olympic gymnast of all time?

One might arguebut Simone Biles vs Nadia Comaneci could easily be the Olympic gymnastics equivalent to Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo. So, who is the better one between these two female athletes? Let's find out what stats and historysay.

Published by

By martina alcheva

Simone Biles (left) and Nadia Comaneci (right). (Getty)
Simone Biles (left) and Nadia Comaneci (right). (Getty)

To speak of the past and present of Gymnastics is to remember Nadia Comaneci of Romania at the 1976 Montreal Olympic Games, and to be surprised by the current situation of Simone Biles of theUnited States, who sealed her ticket to participate in Tokyo 2020 and at 24 years of age, she is shaping up to be one of the best gymnasts in history.

One has undoubted supremacy and the other an accuracy which no one couldmatch.Both have spent their Olympic careers competing against time and themselves rather than against the competition. Comparisons between the two are inevitable, however, each gymnast responds to a time in which the sport has evolved.

While Biles will aim to become the firstin women’s gymnasts in more than 50years to become anOlympic champion for the second time in a rowwhen she walks in front of the world in Tokyo, let’s take a look at here legacy and the one ofNadia Comaneci’s from another period of time.

Advertisement

Simone Biles: The greatest Olympic gymnast of all time?

Simone Biles of the US competes on the vault in 2019. (Getty)

Simone Biles of the US competes on the vault in 2019. (Getty)

After appearing at her first OlympicGames in Rio 2016, Simone Biles has managed to enter the category of Olympic legends. The United States gymnast captivated the world with her smile and technique in Rio de Janeiro.

Advertisement

In 2016, her routines earned her four gold medals in individual and team all-around competitions, floor exercises, and vault. In addition, she earnedthe bronze on the balance beam, a test in which Comaneci grabbed no other result than the golden metal. For the Tokyo Olympics, Biles will be one of the athletes to watch.

Shecould surpass Nadia Comaneci in gold metals and in the same way, she could pass her in the total of Olympic medals, since four podiums are enough to reach her.The evolution of sportsis so remarkable and gymnastics is no exception. The disciplineshave changed over the years and now, the technical difficulty is getting higher, so Simone Biles has a bigger challenge in the Japanese capital to aim for a spot aboveComaneci.

Advertisement

Nadia Comaneci: The greatest Olympic gymnast of all time?

Nadia Comaneci of Romania performs her balance beam routine in 1978. (Getty)

Nadia Comaneci of Romania performs her balance beam routine in 1978. (Getty)

At 14 years old, Nadia Comaneci achieved perfection. She made it to the Montreal Olympics to go down in history after hitting the perfect 10 on the uneven bars and after that, she couldn’t stop doing it. The Romanian gymnast continued to add perfect grades to win three gold medals.

Advertisement

She also climbed to the top of the podium in the individual all-around and balance beam competitions, addingto her achievements a medal silver and a bronze to close the 1976 Games as the most outstanding athlete by winning five medals at ayoung age.

Four years later, at the 1980 Moscow Games, Comaneci added two more gold medals to herlegacy. Again, she turned out to be thebest one on the balance beam, and on the floor, exercises were named after her as well. In addition, sheleft with two silver medals to close herOlympic cycle with a total of nine medals.

Advertisement

Today the format of the Olympic score system is somewhat different, asgymnasts will now be granted the most points judging bythe complexity of the routines, and ifthe judges detect any errors, the points will be deducted. However, it was Comaneci’s innovation that put her on the top. Her creativity and the technical excellence that she sought in each of the tests that she carried out, continue to influence new generations, including the USgymnastSimone Biles.

Many more people andgymnasts over the world willshare their opinion,as the argument over who is the all-time greatest Olympic gymnastwill carry on. However, as the next generation of athletes emerges, it’ssafe toconclude there won’t ever beanotherSimone Biles, nor anotherNadia Comaneci.

Advertisement

ALSO READ

NFL News: Chiefs HC Andy Reid admits delaying return of key weapon for Patrick Mahomes
NFL

NFL News: Chiefs HC Andy Reid admits delaying return of key weapon for Patrick Mahomes

NFL News: Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa sends heartfelt message to Patriots' Drake Maye
NFL

NFL News: Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa sends heartfelt message to Patriots' Drake Maye

NBA News: Norman Powell sends clear message to Sixers' Paul George on "Clippers Wall"
NBA

NBA News: Norman Powell sends clear message to Sixers' Paul George on "Clippers Wall"

NHL News: Capitals star Tom Wilson sends straightforward message about Alex Ovechkin's injury
NHL

NHL News: Capitals star Tom Wilson sends straightforward message about Alex Ovechkin's injury

Better Collective Logo