Vikings HC Kevin O’Connell reveals key reason he chose J.J. McCarthy over Aaron Rodgers ahead of 2025 NFL season

One of the most interesting storylines in this past NFL offseason was the one involving the Minnesota Vikings and the potential signing of former Super Bowl champion Aaron Rodgers. In the end, head coach Kevin O’Connell decided to go with the young talent of J.J. McCarthy and revealed an interesting reason why he did not move forward with pursuing the former Jets QB.

Rodgers’ talent is well known, and it could have elevated an offense looking to contend in the NFC North. However, age and injuries were not minor factors when it came time to decide on the new starter for the Vikings, a team with a long-term vision for the franchise.

During an in-studio appearance on KFAN-FM 100.3, HC O’Connell mentioned the conversations he had with the former Packers standout during the offseason, where he expressed his intention to go with McCarthy despite the rumors surrounding the veteran QB’s potential arrival in Minnesota.

“When there was an opportunity — when him and I connected this offseason just to kind of talk about what that would look like — we had a lot of great dialogue about it, but it always was centered around what was best not only for the present in the Minnesota Vikings organization, but the future.

“I was very honest about my feelings toward’s J.J., my obligation that I felt like we were going to give him the best possible situation to begin and thrive on this NFL journey and let’s see where it goes. We stayed in touch and had some communication,” O’Connell firmly stated.

McCarthy is O’Connell’s chosen one

J.J. McCarthy’s arrival in the NFL was met with high hopes within the Vikings organization. However, a severe injury early last season prevented him from making his official debut for Minnesota.

Now back to full health, the talented quarterback is showing this offseason why the coach was right to place his bet on him as the starter — and that’s something Kevin O’Connell is well aware of.

“He’s having a great spring,” the head coach said. “We’re pretty darn close to having a good feel for where he’s at. He’s had a great offseason. He’s healthy, strong, throwing the ball great, fundamentals — everything you hope for in the spring.”