Vancouver Canucks star Quinn Hughes has consistently impressed as one of the league’s premier puck-moving defensemen. Over the last three seasons, Hughes has posted at least 76 points per campaign, including a 92-point season in 2023-24, earning him the Norris Trophy and solidifying his reputation as an elite talent.

Despite his on-ice production, questions have arisen about Hughes’ ability to guide Vancouver to a Stanley Cup, particularly with his future in the city uncertain. Comments earlier this year by Jim Rutherford hinted that Hughes’ next contract negotiations may not hinge solely on money or term, suggesting organizational uncertainty regarding the team’s long-term core around him.

A former NHL player recently weighed in on the topic during the Empty Netters Podcast, expressing skepticism about Hughes’ ability to lead a championship team. “If you want my personal opinion, I don’t think you win a [Stanley] Cup with that man,” said former defenseman James Wisniewski. “Dude, this kid is unbelievable. He’s way better than me. I’m not saying anything. I’m just saying as an all-around game, as a winner that’s not your Zdeno Chara, right?”

What did James Wisniewski say about Hughes?

Wisniewski compared Hughes to other top defensemen like Cale Makar, Adam Fox, and Lane Hutson, noting that Hughes doesn’t necessarily belong in that group as a proven Stanley Cup winner. While all four blueliners are talented, only Makar has lifted the Cup, highlighting that championship success requires more than individual skill.

Quinn Hughes #43 of the Vancouver Canucks takes the puck in the third period against the New Jersey Devils at Prudential Center on March 24, 2025 in Newark, New Jersey. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

Can one player lead a team to glory?

While Wisniewski’s remarks raise eyebrows, it’s important to remember that winning a Stanley Cup involves contributions from all four lines, three defensive pairings performing at a high level, and goaltenders stepping up when needed.

Hughes’ skill and vision are undeniable, but team success depends on more than a single player’s leadership. Fans will be watching closely this season to see if Hughes and the Canucks can overcome these doubts and mount a serious playoff push.

SURVEY Do you believe Quinn Hughes can lead the Vancouver Canucks to a Stanley Cup?

Do you believe Quinn Hughes can lead the Vancouver Canucks to a Stanley Cup?

Yes, he’s the leader they need
No, the team needs more depth
Unsure, it depends on supporting cast

already voted 34 fans