MLB

Brandon Marsh’s return triggers social media outcry from Phillies fans

The Philadelphia Phillies made the official announcement just hours before their game against the Diamondbacks, but the fan reaction to Brandon Marsh’s return on social media was anything but favorable.

Brandon Marsh #16 of the Philadelphia Phillies looks on after striking out in the bottom of the eighth inning against the New York Yankees at Citizens Bank Park on July 31, 2024 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Yankees defeated the Phillies 6-5.
© Getty ImagesBrandon Marsh #16 of the Philadelphia Phillies looks on after striking out in the bottom of the eighth inning against the New York Yankees at Citizens Bank Park on July 31, 2024 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Yankees defeated the Phillies 6-5.

Brandon Marsh had been sidelined with an injury since mid-April, which led the Philadelphia Phillies to turn to Johan Rojas in center field — and he has impressed with outstanding defense and a strong showing at the plate. But with Marsh now officially back in the lineup, fans voiced frustration on X following the team’s announcement.

Most of the replies to the Phillies’ official post on X (@Phillies) were not supportive of Marsh’s return. Many fans expressed concern that Rojas, who has been thriving, could be pushed aside. “Rojas has already proven he’s an everyday player in center field. I love Marsh and I always will, but he’s just not it,” wrote user @zeglerverse.

There’s no question fans want Rojas to remain the starting center fielder. “I’m going to flip if this dude gets playing time over Rojas,” one fan posted, echoing the sentiment. Rojas, a Dominican outfielder, is currently hitting over .300 and has delivered solid performances during Marsh’s absence.

Advertisement

Fan Pushback Focused on Keeping Rojas in Center

Across several Phillies-focused accounts that shared the roster update, the fan responses were strikingly similar: calls to keep Rojas in center. “Keep Rojas in center,” another user replied in reaction to the Marsh news.

There were, however, a few fans standing up for Marsh, hoping he can return to form. “If we can get the 2023 Marsh that batted .277, slugged .458, and had an .829 OPS back, all these haters would go away,” wrote @Dylan_McDowell on X.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Survey

Who should be Phillies CF?

already voted 0 people

Advertisement
ALSO READ
Are Cowboys eliminated from 2026 NFL playoffs after loss to Vikings on SNF in Week 15?
NFL

Are Cowboys eliminated from 2026 NFL playoffs after loss to Vikings on SNF in Week 15?

Lionel Messi shows humility with message in English about Inter Miami’s successful season
Soccer

Lionel Messi shows humility with message in English about Inter Miami’s successful season

Andy Reid sends clear message as Chiefs are eliminated from playoffs
NFL

Andy Reid sends clear message as Chiefs are eliminated from playoffs

Davante Adams injury update: Sean McVay makes concerning admission ahead of Rams vs Seahawks TNF
NFL

Davante Adams injury update: Sean McVay makes concerning admission ahead of Rams vs Seahawks TNF

Better Collective Logo