Last Tuesday, the NBA announced a revamped format for the 2025 All-Star Game, introducing four teams competing in three separate games on Sunday, February 16, at the Chase Center in the San Francisco Bay Area. However, the reaction from players has been mixed, with stars like Kevin Durant of the Phoenix Suns voicing disapproval. Joining Durant in his criticism are teammates Devin Booker and Los Angeles Lakers star Anthony Davis.
Davis expressed his reservations about the new structure but admitted he’s willing to give it a chance. “I don’t really like it, but we’ll see how it goes this year,” Davis said, adding that he hopes the league reverts to the traditional format. “I want two teams—if anything, go back to East and West.”
Davis’ comments underscore a sentiment that appears to be gaining traction among players: widespread rejection of the new format. “Four teams and multiple games… I don’t think a lot of players are gonna like that,” Davis said, predicting that many players and teams would share his concerns.
Sun’s player Devin Booker also voiced his preference for the classic format, drawing attention to the nostalgic appeal of the old structure. “It’s change; it’s different. I’m more into the nostalgia,” Booker said. “I agree with Kev. I like East vs. West, with your own team jersey. I like the old jerseys.”
Devin Booker of the Phoenix Suns handles the ball against D’Angelo Russell of the Los Angeles
The revamped format raises questions about the quality of play and the level of player engagement. While the NBA has stated its intent to innovate and refresh the All-Star Game experience, the backlash from key players suggests the league may face challenges in gaining widespread acceptance.
see also
Kevin Durant destroys new All-Star format, sends strong request to the NBA
Nostalgia as a Driving Force Behind Player Criticism
Nostalgia has emerged as a recurring theme in players’ critiques of the new All-Star Game format. Devin Booker, in particular, highlighted his preference for the traditional East vs. West setup and the use of team-specific jerseys. His comments reflect a longing for the simplicity and familiarity of the classic structure, which many players associate with honoring the league’s history and traditions.
Lakers star echoed similar sentiments, advocating for a return to the old format while acknowledging the shared skepticism among players. “I don’t think a lot of players are gonna like [the new format],” Davis said. This collective nostalgia underscores a broader desire to preserve the All-Star Game as a celebration of basketball’s essence rather than an experiment in entertainment innovation.
Balancing Tradition and Innovation: The NBA’s Dilemma
The NBA faces a critical challenge: how to balance its rich traditions with the need to innovate and attract younger audiences. While the classic East vs. West format symbolized regional rivalries and offered a straightforward narrative, the new structure introduces a more dynamic and unconventional approach.
The league may be betting on the novelty of four teams and multiple games to create fresh excitement. However, this approach risks alienating long-time fans and players who value the simplicity and historical significance of the All-Star Game.
