MLB

Rob Thomson explains why Phillies didn’t retaliate after Bryce Harper HBP vs Braves

After Bryce Harper was hit by a pitch against the Atlanta Braves, Philadelphia Phillies manager Rob Thomson offered a clear explanation for the team’s response.

Bryce Harper #3 of the Philadelphia Phillies celebrates with teammates after hitting a two-run home run during the eighth inning against the Cleveland Guardians.
© Photo by Nick Cammett/Getty ImagesBryce Harper #3 of the Philadelphia Phillies celebrates with teammates after hitting a two-run home run during the eighth inning against the Cleveland Guardians.

Bryce Harper was removed from the game on Tuesday after being struck on the elbow by a 95-mph fastball from Atlanta Braves starter Spencer Strider. The incident occurred during a regular season matchup at Citizens Bank Park.

The pitch hit the same elbow that Harper had previously injured, prompting immediate attention from the Phillies’ medical staff. Harper exited the game following the play, and the situation generated discussion about a potential response from the Philadelphia team.

The following games came and went without any form of payback. No brushbacks. No inside heat. And no retribution. When asked about the lack of response, Philadelphia’s manager Rob Thomson offered a calm, straightforward answer that set the tone for his team’s approach.

Advertisement

Rob Thomson’s clear message

Rather than inflaming the situation, Thomson addressed the incident with measured clarity. Speaking to reporters before Thursday’s double-header, he dismissed the idea of retaliation.

Tweet placeholder
Advertisement

Because it’s not on purpose. Simple as that, Thomson said. “If I think somebody is throwing at one of our hitters, I don’t know what I’d do, but if it’s a pitch that gets away from a pitcher, which I believe it was, and I think that everybody in that clubhouse thinks it was, that’s baseball. It happens.”

Ex-Phillies GM delivers strong reaction after Bryce Harper gets hit by Braves’ Spencer Strider

see also

His comments drew a line between reckless intent and routine mistakes. In a sport that often thrives on unwritten codes and emotional reactions, the Phillies manager opted for professionalism over provocation.

Advertisement

Reaction from Braves pitcher

Following the incident, Strider showed signs of concern regarding Harper’s condition. No disciplinary action or warnings were issued during or after the game. There was no further escalation between the teams, and gameplay resumed under normal conditions.

Survey

Do you think the Phillies should have retaliated after Bryce Harper was hit?

ALREADY VOTED 0 PEOPLE

Advertisement

Injury update on Harper

Manager Thomson provided a medical update regarding Harper’s status, confirming that the injury did not appear to be serious. Harper is expected to return soon, pending ongoing evaluations and absence of complications. No additional updates have been released by the team regarding his exact timeline for return.

ALSO READ
NY Yankees receive key update on Bellinger amid interest in Tucker as MLB free agency intensifies
MLB

NY Yankees receive key update on Bellinger amid interest in Tucker as MLB free agency intensifies

MLB Rumors: Phillies reportedly set to undergo major roster overhaul involving Castellanos and NY Yankees’ target
MLB

MLB Rumors: Phillies reportedly set to undergo major roster overhaul involving Castellanos and NY Yankees’ target

Philadelphia Phillies are reportedly set to make a decision on crucial player from last season
MLB

Philadelphia Phillies are reportedly set to make a decision on crucial player from last season

Phillies' Dombrowski clarifies Harper comments after 2025 MLB season
MLB

Phillies' Dombrowski clarifies Harper comments after 2025 MLB season

Better Collective Logo