Boxing legend Evander Holyfield casts doubt on Mayweather's victory over Manny Pacquiao

Evander Holyfield, a boxing legend whose legacy stands alongside the sport’s greatest, made a surprising claim regarding Floyd Mayweather’s perfect record. Reflecting on Mayweather’s highly debated 2015 fight against Manny Pacquiao, Holyfield suggested that the outcome may not have been as clear-cut as the official decision indicated.

Mayweather, who retired in 2017 with an impressive 50-0 record, cemented his legacy by winning world titles in five weight divisions, from super featherweight to super welterweight, defeating iconic names such as Manny Pacquiao, Canelo Álvarez, Oscar De La Hoya, and Juan Manuel Márquez. However, Holyfield—himself a fighter of monumental achievements—questions the validity of one of Mayweather’s key victories.

With undisputed reigns at both cruiserweight and heavyweight, Holyfield remains the only four-time heavyweight champion in history. Throughout his storied career, he faced and defeated numerous boxing legends, including Mike Tyson, George Foreman, Larry Holmes, and Riddick Bowe.

Despite the mutual respect between him and Mayweather as two of the sport’s all-time greats, Holyfield has openly disagreed with the outcome of one of Mayweather’s most significant victories.

Floyd Mayweather Jr. celebrates his unanimous-decision victory over Robert Guerrero in their WBC welterweight title bout at the MGM Grand Garden Arena on May 4, 2013.(Al Bello/Getty Images)

The Mayweather-Pacquiao controversy and Holyfield’s opinion

The highest-grossing fight of Mayweather’s career—a long-awaited showdown against Manny Pacquiao in May 2015—generated a record-breaking 4.6 million pay-per-view buys and $72 million at the gate.

see also

Not Holyfield: Boxing legend Lennox Lewis reveals his era's most ‘underrated’ heavyweight

Mayweather secured a unanimous decision victory, but when asked in an ESPN interview after the superfight whether he believed Pacquiao should have won, Holyfield responded bluntly: “I actually thought Pacquiao was doing well. I don’t know how people scored the fight, I thought he was doing well,” His statement, though controversial, reflects the widespread belief that the fight was closer than the official result suggested.

Holyfield’s legacy and his unique perspective on boxing

Evander Holyfield’s willingness to challenge Floyd Mayweather’s perfect record and assert his own greatness underscores his competitive mindset and deep understanding of the sport. As debates over Mayweather’s legacy and Holyfield’s place in boxing history continue, his perspective adds yet another layer to the ongoing conversation in the boxing world.