The Philadelphia Phillies are heading into spring training with a key decision looming at the catcher position. Only one of J.T. Realmuto’s backups is likely to earn a guaranteed roster spot for the 2026 season.
Rafael Marchan and Garrett Stubbs will compete during camp to see who stays with the big-league team. Marchan, 26, has been with the Phillies longer and has more upside, while Stubbs, 32, offers experience and clubhouse leadership.
According to MLB.com’s Paul Casella, “Similar to last year, Rafael Marchan and Garrett Stubbs will come into camp competing to back up starter J.T. Realmuto. Unlike last year, however, neither Marchán nor Stubbs has a Minor League option remaining. That was essentially the deciding factor last year, as Marchán did not have any options remaining and Stubbs did.”
Camp performance likely to decide the backup spot
Both players have similar behind-the-plate skills, but Marchan’s hitting and raw talent may give him an initial edge. Stubbs, meanwhile, has a contract suggesting a longer-term plan if he remains on the roster.
Cristopher Sánchez #61 of the Phillies celebrates with Rafael Marchán #13 and Garrett Stubbs #21 after the game. Mitchell Leff/Getty Images
Salary-wise, Marchan earns $860,000, while Stubbs is on a split deal of $925,000/$575,000. Ultimately, performance during spring training could be the deciding factor.
see also
NY Yankees make key roster move after re-signing veteran first baseman
Longstanding Competition Coming to a Close
The Marchan-Stubbs battle has been ongoing for four years, creating uncertainty at the backup catcher position. With the Phillies entering a critical season, the organization is expected to finally make a clear choice as spring wraps up, bringing an end to the years-long competition behind Realmuto.
SurveyWho do you think should be J.T. Realmuto’s backup for the Phillies in 2026?
Who do you think should be J.T. Realmuto’s backup for the Phillies in 2026?
already voted 0 people
