MLB

Paul O’Neill and Michael Kay stunned by Yankees blunder: ‘It’s like a Little League game out here’

The New York Yankees continue to commit baffling mistakes that make them look like a team with serious fundamental issues. A recent error by one player sparked a strong reaction from both Paul O’Neill and Michael Kay during the broadcast.

Manager Aaron Boone #17 of the New York Yankees looks on during batting practice before the game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Yankee Stadium on April 01, 2025 in the Bronx borough of New York City.
© Getty ImagesManager Aaron Boone #17 of the New York Yankees looks on during batting practice before the game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Yankee Stadium on April 01, 2025 in the Bronx borough of New York City.

The New York Yankees continue to make fundamental mistakes that leave everyone stunned—from opponents to fans to even the broadcast booth. Commentators Michael Kay and Paul O’Neill didn’t hold back after a routine play turned into a costly error late in the game.

“Michael, you get to a point where you just can’t make this up … it’s like a Little League game going on out here,” O’Neill said after a Yankees outfield miscue allowed the Marlins to tie the game at 12 in the top of the 9th inning.

Kay followed up with a sharp response: “This whole game, Paul, kind of has the feel of you’re having a bad dream and you cannot wake up.” The Yankees went on to lose the game 13-12.

Advertisement

The blunder that set off Kay and O’Neill

This time, the error didn’t come from Anthony Volpe—who actually had a strong game against Miami—but rather from José Caballero. The former Rays infielder, recently added to the Yankees roster, was filling in for Aaron Judge in the outfield when the misplay occurred.

Tweet placeholder
Advertisement

Total collapse against the Marlins

The game was a complete disaster for the Yankees. They led 6-0 in the top of the 5th inning but allowed four runs in the frame. Even after extending the lead to 9-4 in the 7th, the bullpen couldn’t hold it, and the Marlins stormed back to take a 10-9 lead. Much of the blame fell on the Yankees’ relief pitching.

“All three relievers that the Yankees acquired, that were so touted,” Kay said. “They all did not do their job tonight… we keep digging new holes, Paul. And this one goes under the worst loss of the year.”

Advertisement
Top 25 MLB franchises with most fans: The most popular baseball teams

see also

ALSO READ
What happens if Finland wins, ties or loses vs Slovakia today in 2026 Winter Olympics men’s hockey bronze medal game?
NHL

What happens if Finland wins, ties or loses vs Slovakia today in 2026 Winter Olympics men’s hockey bronze medal game?

NY Mets’ Devin Williams sends ‘mental toughness’ message ahead of new season
MLB

NY Mets’ Devin Williams sends ‘mental toughness’ message ahead of new season

2026 Winter Olympics: Will Sidney Crosby play in the final for Team Canada vs Team USA?
NHL

2026 Winter Olympics: Will Sidney Crosby play in the final for Team Canada vs Team USA?

Where to watch Al Nassr vs Al Hazm live in the USA: 2025/2026 Saudi Pro League
Soccer

Where to watch Al Nassr vs Al Hazm live in the USA: 2025/2026 Saudi Pro League

Better Collective Logo