NFL

NFL News: Mike Tomlin could be forced to make a shocking decision about Steelers' quarterback room led by Aaron Rodgers

Mike Tomlin faces a tough call in Pittsburgh as the quarterback room heats up. With Aaron Rodgers firmly in command, rising star Skylar Thompson is putting pressure on the depth chart.

NFL News: Mike Tomlin is asked to part ways with Steelers by Pittsburgh Super Bowl champion
NFL News: Mike Tomlin confirms why Steelers didn’t choose Shedeur Sanders in first round of 2025 Draft

August 17, 2025 06:42PM EDT

**© Joe Sargent/Getty Images**Mike Tomlin head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers

Mike Tomlin and the Pittsburgh Steelers could face a very tough decision in the quarterback room led by Aaron Rodgers. After a strong preseason, Skylar Thompson is fighting to earn a spot on the roster in a competition with Mason Rudolph and Will Howard.

At the moment, Rudolph seems to have the edge as Rodgers’ backup due to his familiarity with the team from his first stint between 2018 and 2023. However, the big question is what will happen with Howard.

The rookie shined in mandatory minicamp and in the first days of training camp, but a finger injury has kept him from playing in the preseason with the Steelers. This opened the door for Thompson, who in two games has posted impressive stats: 30 of 43 passes completed, 346 yards, and three touchdowns. Numbers that would secure him a spot on any other NFL team.

Mike Tomlin Praises Skylar Thompson

After the game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, several reporters asked Mike Tomlin if he was surprised by Skylar Thompson’s strong performances. The head coach’s response was decisive.

“It really has not. This guy’s played some NFL football. He’s had some starts and so forth in Miami. So, I’m not surprised that it’s not too big for him. I’m not surprised that his talent is showing. He’s a diligent worker. One man’s misfortune is often times another man’s opportunity. We live by that and certainly Will’s misfortune is his opportunity. He’s taken a nice advantage of it.”

NFL News: Mike Tomlin issues a very strong warning to Aaron Rodgers’ Steelers after preseason loss against Buccaneers

Mike Tomlin Faces Tough QB Dilemma With Steelers

Mike Tomlin will have to decide very soon who will keep the No. 3 spot in the Steelers’ quarterback room. If Will Howard doesn’t play due to his injury, the logical move would be to keep Skylar Thompson on the roster for the start of the 2025 season.

What is certain is that Howard won’t be cut or sent to the practice squad because of his potential as a rookie for the future. The big question is whether, given Thompson’s strong performances, the lack of roster space could surprisingly force the team to cut or maybe trade the former Miami Dolphins quarterback.