MLB

Phillies must make key decision regarding JT Realmuto’s contract standoff

It seems like the Philadelphia Phillies and JT Realmuto are not having the best of days agreeing on a new deal.

J.T. Realmuto #10 of the Philadelphia Phillies
© Emilee Chinn/Getty ImagesJ.T. Realmuto #10 of the Philadelphia Phillies

The Philadelphia Phillies have mande their intentions clear on trying to retain JT Realmuto‘s services at catcher. However, both parties are at a contract standoff, and the possibility of a trade is starting to see more and more feasible.

As Matt Gelb of The Athletic reported, “The Phillies and Realmuto are locked in a standoff, league sources said. A reunion makes sense for both sides. That, still, is the expectation. But, as Realmuto seeks a better offer, the Phillies have pursued trade alternatives.

Acquiring a new backspot is not an easy feat so good trade scenarios must be tough to find as well. Still, there are some names that could be available if Realmuto and the Phillies can’t agree on terms.

Advertisement

One name is a red flag

One of the names circling around the Phillies is Adley Rutschman. The Orioles signed Samuel Basallo to an 8-year, $67 million contract. Hence, Rutschman’s name could become prominent. However, he has been injury prone and his production has taken a big dip the last couple of years.

Adley Rutschman #35 of the Baltimore Orioles

Adley Rutschman #35 of the Baltimore Orioles

Advertisement

The Phillies might get tempted given that Rutschman is a former first-overall pick and also just 27-years-old. However, having an unreliable presence shouldn’t be Realmuto’s replacement. Realmuto gives the Phillies a solid, consistent presence even at 34 years of age.

Phillies reportedly will use Matt Strahm’s trade in a way that will frustrate fans

see also

The Phillies best path is keeping Realmuto

While they are exploring trade possibilities, the fact is the Phillies should do whatever it takes to keep Realmuto on the roster. Getting a new backstop out of the blue is always a tough thing to do, especially one of Realmuto’s quality.

Advertisement

Realmuto might still have a couple of good seasons in him, so you can keep him, and find a good prospect to develop in the meantime. Then, the team can reassess and see what the next steps are.

ALSO READ
Phillies poach big-time talent who played for the Braves as part of their new idea of success going forward
MLB

Phillies poach big-time talent who played for the Braves as part of their new idea of success going forward

Bryce Harper’s new star teammate makes major admission ahead of Phillies’ 2026 MLB season
MLB

Bryce Harper’s new star teammate makes major admission ahead of Phillies’ 2026 MLB season

Dave Dombrowski reveals key piece of Phillies’ 2026 bullpen strategy with Jhoan Duran
MLB

Dave Dombrowski reveals key piece of Phillies’ 2026 bullpen strategy with Jhoan Duran

NY Mets make key move with sights on the future after trade with Athletics
MLB

NY Mets make key move with sights on the future after trade with Athletics

Better Collective Logo