NFL

Vikings News: Three potential replacements for QB J.J. McCarthy

With J.J. McCarthy out for the entire 2024 NFL season, here are three options that the Minnesota Vikings could consider to replace the rookie quarterback.

JJ McCarthy, quarterback of the Minnesota Vikings
© Stephen Maturen/Getty ImagesJJ McCarthy, quarterback of the Minnesota Vikings

The Minnesota Vikings have received devastating news regarding rookie quarterback J.J. McCarthy. He will miss the entire 2024 NFL season due to an injury, forcing the NFC North team to consider potential replacements.

Earlier this year, the Vikings made a bold move at the quarterback position by parting ways with Kirk Cousins and selecting J.J. McCarthy with the 10th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft.

McCarthy impressed in his preseason debut, but a season-ending injury has dashed hopes for his rookie year. Now, the Vikings must quickly devise a backup plan to replace the former Michigan standout.

Advertisement

J.J. McCarthy’s possible replacements at Vikings

Sam Darnold

The leading candidate to replace J.J. McCarthy is Sam Darnold, who was initially slated to be his backup this season. The Vikings signed Darnold before the 2024 NFL Draft, and it now appears he’ll have another opportunity to start.

NFL News: J.J. McCarthy, Vikings get terrible news ahead of 2024 NFL season

see also

Darnold’s career has been underwhelming so far. After leaving the Jets in 2020, he joined the Panthers, where he eventually lost the starting job to Baker Mayfield. Last year, he signed with the 49ers but started only one game as Brock Purdy took the reins.

Advertisement

Ryan Tannehill

Another option for the Vikings is to explore the market for a veteran quarterback. While a trade could be an option, they might find their solution in free agency.

Ryan Tannehill is currently without a team after being replaced by Will Levis at the Titans. He’s seeking a new opportunity, and signing him could be an affordable upgrade over Sam Darnold for the Vikings.

Advertisement

Tom Brady

Are the Vikings well-positioned to entice Tom Brady out of retirement? Absolutely. But is the seven-time Super Bowl champion likely to unretire? Probably not. Still, there’s a slim chance for Minnesota with TB12.

Tom Brady, former quarterback of the Patriots and the Buccaneers

Tom Brady, former quarterback of the Patriots and the Buccaneers

Advertisement

Brady has repeatedly mentioned that he’s still in great shape for a potential comeback. With the Vikings boasting a strong roster and a top-tier wide receiver in Justin Jefferson, this could be the perfect opportunity for Brady to add even more success to his legendary career.

J.J. McCarthy’s injury: What happened to the Vikings’ quarterback?

After his debut with the Vikings in the preseason opener against the Raiders, it was revealed that J.J. McCarthy suffered a tear in his right meniscus and will require surgery.

Advertisement
NFL News: Vikings are awaiting the arrival of a former Tom Brady teammate and Patriots champion

see also

This injury will sideline him for the entire 2024 NFL season, forcing the Vikings to urgently consider their options for a replacement, whether by exploring the market or sticking with their current roster.

Survey

Should the Vikings use Sam Darnold as starter or hire another quarterback?

already voted 0 people

Advertisement
ALSO READ
Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games
NFL

Kevin O’Connell provides key injury update on JJ McCarthy ahead of upcoming Vikings games

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?
NFL

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?

Vikings receive clear warning from Sam Darnold ahead of Seahawks clash
NFL

Vikings receive clear warning from Sam Darnold ahead of Seahawks clash

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks
NFL

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks

Better Collective Logo