NCAA FB

Not Arch Manning: Two QBs emerge as candidates to go first overall in 2026 NFL Draft after Texas’ loss to Ohio State

After a bad performance against Ohio State, Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning is no longer the favorite to be the first overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Two names have emerged heavily in that discussion.

Arch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns.
© Kevin C. Cox/Getty ImagesArch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns.

Everybody expected to see Arch Manning atop the list of possible number one picks in the next NFL Draft. However, after dropping a very underpar performance in the Texas Longhorns vs. Ohio State Buckeyes game, two new names have climbed the ladder and emerged as favorites to get picked first.

Now, Penn State quarterback Drew Allar and LSU signal-caller Garrett Nussmeier are co-favorites according to the Vegas odds. As of now, they both share a +350 line on DraftKings.com.

Nussmeier had an impressive showing against fourth-ranked Clemson. He threw for 230 yards, completing 28 of 38 passes and had a touchdown pass with no turnovers. LSU beat the other Tigers on the road as 4.5-point underdogs.

Advertisement

The Drew Allar experience was in full force for Penn State

Drew Allar is in his fourth season as the Penn State quarterback. He went 22/26 passes completed for 217 yards with a touchdown and no picks. He even sat out the last quarter as the Nittany Lions had a very dominant 46-11 win against Nevada.

Drew Allar

Penn State quarterback Drew Allar (15).

Advertisement

Allar has passed for 25 and 24 touchdowns the last two seasons while getting intercepted 10 times in that same span. He has always been touted as a good prospect, but big games and some disconnected moments during the matches are his biggest flaws. When he is good, he is really good. But sometimes, he can struggle.

Arch Manning makes strong self-critique after Longhorns debut loss

see also

Is Arch Manning third on the list?

Manning’s performance against the Buckeyes left much to be desired, so much so that his name is now fifth on the list of possible number one picks in the upcoming NFL draft. Now, it needs to be said that this market is as volatile as it comes. Every week, with every performance, this can change massively.

Advertisement
  • Drew Allar – QB – Penn State (+350)
  • Garrett Nussmeier – QB – LSU (+350)
  • LaNorris Sellers – QB – South Carolina (+500)
  • Cade Klubnik – QB – Clemson (+550)
  • Arch Manning – QB – Texas (+700)
ALSO READ
Ohio State titans: 25 Buckeyes who redefined college football greatness
College Football

Ohio State titans: 25 Buckeyes who redefined college football greatness

Fans react to Arch Manning’s complicated game in Texas’ loss to Ohio State
College Football

Fans react to Arch Manning’s complicated game in Texas’ loss to Ohio State

Ohio State running back TreVeyon Henderson’s profile: Height, weight, career and more
NFL

Ohio State running back TreVeyon Henderson’s profile: Height, weight, career and more

Patrick Mahomes sends clear message to Andy Reid's Chiefs about playoff chances after loss against Cowboys
NFL

Patrick Mahomes sends clear message to Andy Reid's Chiefs about playoff chances after loss against Cowboys

Better Collective Logo