nfl

Analyst says Colts were fleeced in Sauce Gardner trade

The Indianapolis Colts may have overpaid for their new star.

Sauce Gardner has been traded to the Colts
ยฉ Justin Berl/Getty ImagesSauce Gardner has been traded to the Colts

The Indianapolis Colts are set to capitalize on their success in the first half of the 2025 NFL season. They landed All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner from the New York Jets to bolster their secondary for the second half of the campaign. 

Advertisement

At 7-2, Indianapolis boasts the best record in the league (tied with the New England Patriots), and they arenโ€™t stopping there. Daniel Jones, Jonathan Taylor and Michael Pittman have shone this season, but the defense needed something to reach the next level.

They hope that Gardner can elevate their game, especially considering that the cornerback position is experiencing a shortage. However, not everybody is convinced the Colts made a good move. 

Advertisement

Analyst says Colts gave up too much for Sauce Gardner 

In the wake of the blockbuster trade between the Colts and Jets, NFL analyst Pete Prisco disagreed with the move, saying that the Colts gave a lot for a player who hasnโ€™t lived up to expectations. 

Sauce Gardner #1 of the New York Jets

Sauce Gardner #1 of the New York Jets

Advertisement

โ€œA reach? This is robbery,โ€ Prisco said. โ€œNot only are you getting two first-round picks back, youโ€™re giving up an enormous salary. So the Colts are giving away two first-round picks for corner who has a big salary and hasnโ€™t quite played up to expectations. This is a desperation move by the Indianapolis Colts. Sauce Gardner at best is a really good player, but heโ€™s not worth two number ones.โ€

Gardner is expected to make his debut against the Atlanta Falcons on Sunday. Going against a player like Drake London could show Prisco and others where the cornerback stands among the best in his position. 

Advertisement
ALSO READ
Colts provide quick injury update on Sauce Gardner as star CB exits Texans game early
NFL

Colts provide quick injury update on Sauce Gardner as star CB exits Texans game early

Sauce Gardner throws shade at Jets after being traded to the Colts
NFL

Sauce Gardner throws shade at Jets after being traded to the Colts

Sauce Gardner warned the Jets about what would happen if they ever traded him
NFL

Sauce Gardner warned the Jets about what would happen if they ever traded him

Where to watch Benfica vs Sporting CP live for in the USA: 2025/2026 Primeira Liga
Soccer

Where to watch Benfica vs Sporting CP live for in the USA: 2025/2026 Primeira Liga

Better Collective Logo