Reaching the Super Bowl is a dream moment for every player who turns pro. Having the chance to lift the Vince Lombardi Trophy is an unforgettable moment for every star and key weapon of the league’s franchises. However, the triumph may not come and there is a long list of NFL quarterbacks who lost their first Super Bowl.
For a quarterback, making it to the Super Bowl can be a career milestone that transcends the final score. It is a game that can make talent and performance unquestionable after leading a team through the regular season and playoffs. Losing a Super Bowl is painful for any NFL QB, especially the first time.
The list of quarterbacks who have won their first Super Bowl is long, including Tom Brady of the New England Patriots. However, there are also a considerable number of stars who lost their first one. Some have managed to return, while others have failed in the attempt. These are some of the most notable names in recent years.
Drake Maye – Super Bowl LX
Drake Maye #10 of the New England Patriots.
Despite an encouraging campaign that led to an unlikely trip to Santa Clara, nothing went to plan for Drake Maye and the New England Patriots in Super Bowl LX. The offense couldn’t get things going against the Seattle Seahawks, who handed Maye a loss in his first Super Bowl start. Sam Darnold, also making his first start in the big game, gained the upper hand this time.
Jalen Hurts – Super Bowl LVII
Jalen Hurts lost the 2023 Super Bowl to the Kansas City Chiefs with the Philadelphia Eagles. However, he proved that it is possible to come back in a short time. Two years after his initial defeat, Hurts redeemed himself with a commanding 40-22 with the Eagles, precisely against the Chiefs.
Jalen Hurts, quarterback of the Eagles.
Joe Burrow – Super Bowl LVI
Just like Maye, the case of Joe Burrow is an example that it is possible to reach the Super Bowl even if a quarterback is in his second season as a professional. The Cincinnati Bengals star led his team by contributing a touchdown, but was unable to defeat the Rams in Super Bowl LVI, played in 2022.
Joe Burrow, quarterback for the Cincinnati Bengals
Jared Goff – Super Bowl LIII
Jared Goff played in Super Bowl LIII 53 on February 3, 2019, when he was the quarterback of the Los Angeles Rams. In this game, his team fell when facing the New England Patriots of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. Goff struggled to move the offense, as the Rams scored only 3 points, the fewest in a Super Bowl since 1972.
Jared Goff #16 of the Detroit Lions looks on during warmups prior to a game.
Matt Ryan – Super Bowl LI
Among the stars who are no longer active is Matt Ryan, who played in only one Super Bowl in his career, and it ended in defeat. The Atlanta Falcons quarterback was also unable to defeat Brady’s Patriots, losing 28-34 in overtime during the NFL final in February 2017.
Matt Ryan during warm-up before a Falcons game.
Cam Newton – Super Bowl 50
Cam Newton lost Super Bowl 50 playing for the Carolina Panthers against the Denver Broncos in a game that ended in a 10-24 defeat. Newton did not have his best performance in the game, facing a Broncos defense led by Von Miller that constantly pressured him. He was sacked six times.
Cam Newton while playing against the Denver Broncos during Super Bowl 50.
Other quarterbacks who lost their first Super Bowl
You can name several famous quarterbacks in the NFL who lost their first league final in previous years. Such is the case of Jimmy Garoppolo, who lost the Super Bowl in 2020 while playing for the San Francisco 49ers.
Coincidentally, another notable player who has failed to win the Super Bowl is Colin Kaepernick, who also suffered a loss while with the 49ers in 2013. Rex Grossman, Matt Hasselbeck, Donovan McNabb, Jake Delhomme, Rico Gannon, Kerry Collins and Steve McNair are other QBs who failed to win the NFL Finals.
