NCAA FB

A QB, not Arch Manning, is the new betting favorite to be the first overall pick in 2026 NFL Draft

Arch Manning has struggled this season and, amid all the chaos, a new quarterback has risen to the top of the odds to be selected first overall in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Arch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns.
Ā© Tim Warner/Getty ImagesArch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns.

At the beginning of the College Football season, Texas Longhornsā€˜ quarterback Arch Manning was regarded as the best prospect and likely the first overall pick in the upcoming 2026 NFL Draft. After a few weeks, it’s now another signal-caller the odds-on favorite to be the number one pick.

According to Vegas’ odds, it’s Alabama QB Ty Simpson the favorite to be the first overall pick, with a line set on +220. He is followed by Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza at +290.

South Carolina QB LaNorris Sellers is at +600 right now. He is then followed by Dante Moore of Oregon at +750. The first non-QB on the list to be selected first overall is Miami defensive end Rueben Bain at +800.

Advertisement

Ty Simpson has been stellar for the Crimson Tide

In 2025, Simpson is leading the SEC in three different categories. He leads the SEC in completions (177), touchdown passes (20) and Adjusted Yards gained per pass attempt (9.73). He is also completing 67.8% of his passes, and has only one interception.

Ty Simpson #15 of the Alabama Crimson Tide.

Ty Simpson #15 of the Alabama Crimson Tide.

Advertisement

Alabama is 7-1 too, which helps Simpson’s case. Bama also has an SEC record of 5-0 in 2025. Simpson, who is 6’2″ could be on the loop for a big-time NFL move. Many teams are on the lookout for a quarterback and a rookie sensation like him could definitely tempt plenty of franchises.

Steve Sarkisian reveals new development on Arch Manning’s injury recovery as Texas prepares for Vanderbilt

see also

What are Arch Manning’s odds now?

Arch Manningā€˜s struggles have taken a toll on his odds. Right now, his odds stand at +4000. His stocks have devaluated massively. Manning’s numbers have not been precisely other-worldly.

Advertisement

He is completing only 60.9%, has 1,795 yards, 15 touchdowns and six interceptions. However, his debt is in the big games, where Arch has been exposed. He is still raw.

ALSO READ
Manning waits for No. 1 transfer's final decision as former SEC rival joins Texas
College Football

Manning waits for No. 1 transfer's final decision as former SEC rival joins Texas

Manning at risk of losing key help as Texas battles for former Sanders teammate
College Football

Manning at risk of losing key help as Texas battles for former Sanders teammate

Arch Manning expected to lose Texas weapon to Deion Sanders, Colorado
College Football

Arch Manning expected to lose Texas weapon to Deion Sanders, Colorado

Arch Manning loses high-ceiling teammate after Auburn star Cam Coleman transfers to Texas
College Football

Arch Manning loses high-ceiling teammate after Auburn star Cam Coleman transfers to Texas

Better Collective Logo