NFL

Why is JJ McCarthy not playing today for Vikings vs Bengals in Week 3 of 2025 NFL season?

The Minnesota Vikings are playing against the Cincinnati Bengals as part of the Week 3 action of the 2025 NFL season. With another player under center, why is JJ McCarthy not playing?

J.J. McCarthy #9 of the Minnesota Vikings
© David Berding/Getty ImagesJ.J. McCarthy #9 of the Minnesota Vikings

The Minnesota Vikings and the Cincinnati Bengals will provide a backup vs. backup game in Week 3 of the 2025 NFL season. Carson Wentz will be under center for the purple and gold, but why? What happened to JJ McCarthy?

During Week 2, JJ McCarthy suffered an injury that was later confirmed to be an ankle sprain, which will sideline him for at least a couple of weeks. He avoided IR, but Tracy Wolfson of CBS Sports reports that he is likely to come back in Week 7. For now, it’s Wentz’s chance to command the Vikings offense.

McCarthy struggled to move the chains in his first two games of the season, with only one quarter of very good football in Week 1 against the Bears. However, the rest of his output has been below par.

Advertisement

Wentz is a very different quarterback

Usually, teams like to have a similar style of quarterbacks on their depth chart. Therefore, if there is an injury or something happens, the playbook doesn’t need to change much. However, that’s not always possible and the Vikings know that. McCarthy is a much more reserved, safe quarterback. Sometimes he lacks aggressiveness to throw it downfield or to seek big plays.

Carson Wentz #11 of the Minnesota Vikings

Carson Wentz #11 of the Minnesota Vikings

Advertisement

Wentz is the opposite. Sometimes it’d be better if he tone it down a bit, instead of making some wild plays trying to create magic out of nowhere. They are two polar opposites. Now, it’s time for their head coach Kevin O’Connell to try and make Wentz a more careful quarterback with the upside of trying to get big yardage every now and then.

Kevin O’Connell’s Vikings will lose two key starters ahead of Week 3 showdown vs Bengals

see also

The Vikings are also facing a backup QB

Fortunately for the Vikings, they face the Bengals but they don’t face Joe Burrow, who is not playing today after suffering a turf toe injury, which will require surgery. For the next three months, it’s Jake Browning under center for the team.

Advertisement

This means it’s a battle of backup quarterbacks, but between the two, Wentz should be regarded as the better one of both given his career compared to Browning’s. Wentz was a franchise quarterback at one point in his career, Browning has always been a backup.

ALSO READ
Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?
NFL

Why is Max Brosmer and not JJ McCarthy playing today for Vikings vs Seahawks in NFL Week 13?

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks
NFL

Vikings get hit with JJ McCarthy news ahead of their Week 13 game vs Seahawks

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?
NFL

What happens if the Vikings lose or win against Packers today in Week 12 of 2025 NFL season?

Vikings get massive boost for JJ McCarthy’s offense for key Week 12 game vs Packers
NFL

Vikings get massive boost for JJ McCarthy’s offense for key Week 12 game vs Packers

Better Collective Logo